What is the 4th Turning and what are the Implications for Civil Security?

The Fourth Turning is a theory proposed by historians William Strauss and Neil Howe in their 1997 book titled “The Fourth Turning: An American Prophecy.” The theory suggests that history can be divided into four generational cycles, or “turnings,” each lasting about 20-25 years. These turnings are characterized by distinct social, political, and cultural dynamics.

1. First Turning: High (The High) – This is a period of strong institutions and societal unity. It follows a crisis period and is marked by a sense of rebuilding and cultural conformity. Individuals tend to prioritize community and cooperation.
2. Second Turning: Awakening (The Awakening) – In this period, societal institutions are questioned and challenged. People become more individualistic and less conformist. There’s a focus on personal empowerment and social change.
3. Third Turning: Unraveling (The Unraveling) – This is a time of increased skepticism towards institutions and a decline in trust in authority. Individualism and personal rights are emphasized. Society becomes more fragmented and polarized.
4. Fourth Turning: Crisis (The Crisis) – This is the culmination of the cycle, characterized by a major crisis or upheaval that reshapes society. Institutions and norms are challenged, and there’s a call for strong collective action to address the crisis. This turning sets the stage for the next First Turning.

Strauss and Howe’s theory suggests that these turnings are cyclical and predictable, and they argue that American history follows this pattern. They believed that each Fourth Turning represents a significant challenge or event that forces society to come together and make fundamental changes.

Critics of the theory argue that it oversimplifies historical events and social dynamics, and that not all historical periods neatly fit into this four-part structure. Nonetheless, the theory has gained some popularity and attention for its attempt to provide a framework for understanding the cyclical nature of history and generational shifts.

The impact of the Fourth Turning theory on civil security would largely depend on the specific events and dynamics of the crisis period that it predicts. In the Fourth Turning, a major crisis or upheaval is expected to occur, which could have significant implications for civil security. Here are a few potential ways in which civil security could be affected:

1. Increased Tensions and Polarization: During a crisis period, societal tensions and polarization could escalate. This could lead to protests, demonstrations, and conflicts between various groups with differing ideologies. Maintaining civil security and preventing violent clashes would become a challenge.
2. Economic Disruptions: The crisis could be accompanied by economic disruptions such as recessions or depressions. High unemployment rates and financial instability could lead to social unrest and potentially criminal activities. Ensuring the security of individuals, businesses, and public spaces would be crucial.
3. Challenges to Law and Order: As institutions are questioned and trust in authority declines, challenges to law and order might arise. Law enforcement agencies may face difficulties in maintaining control, especially if there’s widespread disillusionment with the government or the legal system.
4. Emergency Response and Preparedness: A major crisis could require significant emergency response and preparedness efforts. Civil security agencies would need to be well-equipped to handle various scenarios, ranging from natural disasters to civil unrest. Adequate planning and coordination would be essential.
5. Cybersecurity Concerns: In today’s interconnected world, cybersecurity is a crucial aspect of civil security. A crisis could lead to increased cyber threats, including hacking attempts, misinformation campaigns, and attacks on critical infrastructure. Protecting digital systems and information would be vital.
6. Community Policing and Engagement: Maintaining civil security during a crisis might require a shift in policing strategies. Community engagement and communication would become paramount to understand local dynamics, address concerns, and prevent violence.
7. Humanitarian and Refugee Issues: Depending on the nature of the crisis, there could be humanitarian and refugee challenges. Ensuring the safety and well-being of displaced populations and providing necessary support would be essential to maintaining civil security.

It’s important to note that the Fourth Turning theory is a theoretical framework and not a deterministic prediction of specific events. While it offers insights into potential societal patterns, the actual impact on civil security would be influenced by a complex interplay of factors, including the nature of the crisis, the response of institutions, and the actions of individuals and communities.

As history has shown, the ways in which civil security is affected during crises can vary widely based on the unique circumstances of each period.

Regardless, society can best prepare by investing in mechanisms that strengthen resilience. 

Marshal is a powerful, exclusive digital marketing platform that helps to simplify and scale access to the complex Security Risk Management and Resilience market, in order to develop opportunities, drive growth and achieve objectives across conflict zones to cyberspace.